
In this day and age most relationships are found on a dating app. Love it or hate it, it’s the predominant way that people meet these days!
Both Next Evolution Matchmaking and Vida Select were designed to simplify this process for busy singles who simply don’t have the time or desire to manage dating apps on their own. Both Vida and NEM handle everything, from creating your profile, to writing your messages, to acquiring dates, so that you can focus on all the things you love doing, while their experts take over all the tedious aspects of online dating.
The question is, which company is more equipped to provide the services you need? Let’s dive in.
Vida Select operates with a very large team, providing services to an extremely broad clientele. The company has scaled itself to a large staff, allowing them to cater their services to a tremendous amount of clients at once. While they can offer memberships to more people than Next Evolution Matchmaking, this large-scale approach may lead to a less personalized experience, making members feel like a mere face in an endless crowd.
In contrast, Next Evolution Matchmaking has always maintained its desire to maintain a smaller and more intimate staff, to create a more boutique experience. Each matchmaker at NEM is permitted a maximum of 5 clients to manage at once. This combined approach of a smaller staff with limited clients allows each client to receive highly personalized attention without sacrificing quality, along with services that can be tailored to their exact needs. Clients benefit from direct interactions with professionals who are deeply invested in their success on a more personal level.
The Winner: Next Evolution Matchmaking

Scott Valdez, the founder of Vida Select, has built a company that integrates human psychology with data science to help clients find compatible matches. He has been working with online daters since 2009 and has developed an excellent reputation over the years, being featured in publications that include The New York Times, Men’s Health, and The Washington Post.
Joshua Pompey, the founder of Next Evolution Matchmaking, has also been helping online daters since 2009 and is widely recognized as the best online dating expert in the world. Having been featured on platforms such as Good Morning America and CNBC, Pompey brings tremendous expertise and hands-on involvement in guiding clients through the dating landscape.
The Winner: Tie – Both have a strong reputation in the field

Vida Select outsources its matchmakers remotely and across the country, allowing them to cover a broader client base by not having to provide direct in-house oversight. However, with such a large staff, this outsourcing can lead to inconsistencies in quality and skillset. Vida matchmakers are reported to be a bit of a mixed bag depending on the luck of the client.
At Next Evolution Matchmaking, all staff members are personally trained by Joshua Pompey, ensuring a consistent, high-quality experience for every client. This hands-on training approach by Joshua Pompey and direct oversight of all his staff members ensures consistent quality across the board.
The Winner: Next Evolution Matchmaking

A common critique of larger matchmaking services like Vida Select is the use of canned openers and pre-packaged messages. While this might be slightly effective if you are just attempting to play a numbers game and spam out hundreds of messages, this approach can often lead to impersonal interactions and lower response rates from high quality matches.
Next Evolution Matchmaking sets itself apart by always crafting individualized and personalized messages that are specifically tailored to each profile being targeted. This personalized communication strategy enhances engagement and increases response rates.
The Winner: Next Evolution Matchmaking
With custom-crafted messages designed for each individual, NEM ensures more authentic and successful interactions.
Vida Select offers general coaching and messaging assistance, but its large-scale approach often results in a less intimate client experience. Responses to clients often take longer, and support may be limited to standard business hours.
NEM offers clients unlimited texting access to its employees and highly tailored coaching. Since the dating world never stops, clients are able to text their matchmakers for advice even on weekends and outside standard business hours, usually receiving a response within 5 minutes. This level of responsiveness ensures clients feel supported and confident throughout their dating journey. The goal is as intimate a connection with the matchmaker as possible.
Winner: Next Evolution Matchmaking
While both Vida Select and Next Evolution Matchmaking provide a vast amount of services for dating apps, Next Evolution Matchmaking emerges as the superior choice. With a boutique approach, industry-leading expertise, highly trained staff, customized communication, and unmatched responsiveness, NEM offers clients the best possible experience in finding meaningful, lasting connections.
Want to Learn More About How Next Evolution Matchmaking Can Help You?

Click below and learn why we have been able to find relationships for our clients on online dating sites and apps at a success rate of over 99%!
Click Here to Learn More!